The Top 20 Hardcore Punk LPs ever recorded. Video below, taking you through my selection and then reasons and justifications for each below. Let me know what you think...
Making a list like this is always hard. There are so many classics,
over 30 years of quality music and so many sub genres that even setting the
criteria for inclusion is difficult. I decided that to make the list it had to
be pretty much pure hardcore, influential, aggressive, a great live act, a
personal favourite, genuine and stood the test of time. It happens so often in
this genre of music that a new release comes out and it’s the best thing since
sliced bread for 3 months. Its listened to daily and then something else comes
out and it’s never listened to again. I also decided on only one LP per band,
no live albums, no EPs and no compilations or discographies (though rules are
made to be broken). A lot of classic releases were just EPs or even demos, but
I decided on LPs only. It was also really hard to pick the order, though in my
opinion each release generally fits into each quarter and for me the top three
are cast in stone. I enjoyed putting it together and had to listen to certain
albums back to back to decide which one would make it in. I’m interested in
everyone else’s opinion or if you think I’ve criminally missed out something.
Anyway, onto the justifications...
20. Avail – 4am Friday
I love Avail. From Satiate through to Front Porch Stories
they have never released a poor album. They are a bit different to most HC
bands in that they get more aggressive with each release. I first saw them live
at the Red Eye in London, where I only went along to see the support band
Assert. I contemplated putting in 7 seconds or Gorilla Biscuits here, which I
think most people would think would be a more suitable or classic choice. But
for me Avail had to make the list, as they make my top 10 bands of all time
list. They haven’t played live since 2008, but haven’t officially split up. Let’s
hope the hiatus comes to an end soon.
19. Tragedy – Tragedy
Tragedy, formed from the ashes of his hero is gone (pun
intended). They have a very strong dis-core influence and very D.I.Y. Most of
the bands on this list are more mainstream underground, where Tragedy is
probably the most underground. A great live band and well worth checking out.
Everybody will have their own favourite ‘anarcho’ hardcore punk band and this
is mine, though I think they musically offer a lot more. In time, this LP could
easily climb this list.
18. The Exploited – Troops of Tomorrow
Punks not dead at all! Some would put The Exploited under
the punk umbrella but for me it’s hardcore punk and so makes the list. Great
riffs and vocals so as all the right ingredients. They have been going for so
long now and have never disappointed.
17. Shelter – Mantra
Another personal favorite from another band which is one of
my favorites. Its probably one of the more mellower records on the list and a
lot of people would swap it with a Youth of Today record, but not me. Their
later LP ‘When 20 Summers Pass’, is also definitely worth checking out if you've
not been exposed to too much Shelter.
16. Slapshot – 16 Valve Hate
I
contemplated Chokes former band ‘SS Decontrol’, as they have released a few
classics, but for me Slapshot are the better band. Just the opening guitar riff
does it and then it never lets up. A personal fav, but you could easily put in ‘Back
on the Map’, ‘Step on It’, or ‘Old Time Hardcore’. Just great straight up
hardcore.
15. Poison Idea – Feel the Darkness
Poison Idea, the heaviest band on the planet – literally. I
guess you've all heard that one before. The first band on the list which I've
not seen live, but people I know who have seen them say they know what they’re
doing. A lot of classics on here, ‘Alan’s on Fire’, ‘The badge’ (I almost used
that song for my Uzbekistan video) and the opener ‘Plastic Bomb’. Great Stuff!
14. M.D.C. – M.D.C.
An often over looked band. I got lent this LP a long time
ago and had never heard of them. I loved it though not quite so impressed with
some of their later releases. They have a lot of reasons to be angry and it
comes across. There was no way this wasn't making the cut.
13. Madball – Legacy
Up until now, with the slight exception of Avail, it’s been
pretty easy to pick each bands best album. It was very hard to do for Madball.
Do I go with the ‘Ball of Destruction’, with all the classics or even their
proper debut of ‘Set it Off’. For me though their best period is ‘Hold it Down’,
‘NYHC EP’ and ‘Legacy’. A modern day classic from a band which will never let anyone
down. Its probably their most aggressive LP and I love it!
12. The Misfits – Static Age
A tricky one here ... for me The Misfits have always been
more Punk than Hardcore Punk, band but who am I to split hairs (or devils
locks). They are so influential and distinctive that it didn't seem right to
leave them out. It was actually pretty tricky to pick out an LP of theirs as
all the classic tunes are usually listened to off compilations these days, so I
picked the LP with the most classics on.
11. The Dead Kennedys – Plastic Surgery
Disasters
I almost put the ‘In god we Trust EP’, here but in obeying
the no EP rule I had to pick an LP. This one is a bit better than their debut,
you normally see on lists like this, for me and on CD has the just mentioned EP
tagged on the end. A very influential band, but more on the alternative post
hardcore style which formed out of hardcore.
10. Sick of it All – Built to Last
Again, very similar to Madball, which LP to pick? I first
saw these on the ‘Just Look Around’ tour years and years ago and are the band I've
seen most live. There is most definitely a reason why I've always gone back to
see them... and that’s the humour of Lou Koller. For me the Built-Call-Yours
trilogy of LPs is their best period, so it was hard to pick one of those three.
I went for Built, due to the title track, ‘Good Looking Out’, and ‘Busted’. ‘Live
in a Dive’ was released at the height of this period and makes it into my top
10 LPs of all time list, as live LPs are allowed in that one.
9. Black Flag – Damaged
This is usually number one in other lists like this I’ve
seen. A great band, but for me a touch over rated hence the lowly top 10
position here. This is easily their best LP though and very influential. Their
4-bar flag logo is probably the most tattooed band symbols ever along with the
SOIA dragon and misfits skull.
8. Minor Threat – Complete Discography
Rules
are made to be broken, just like the discography one. I could have broken the ‘no
EP’ one and just had their debut EP in here, but then I’m missing out ‘Out of
Step’. I had to break one of the rules as a top 20 hardcore list with no minor
threat would be like watching Motorhead without Lemmy. Just not right. This
band also unintentionally spawned the ‘straight edge’ genre. Fine, be positive,
live healthy, but why label and pigeon hole yourself? This would have been
higher on the list, but as it’s a discography and includes everything they have
ever recorded it does tail of a bit towards the end.
7. Suicidal Tendencies – Suicidal Tendencies
I almost didn't include this and then why is it so high once
I did decide to include it. It would make the very top of a crossover list
which is why I almost left it out, but it’s such a great record from such a
great band I changed my mind. Always a very distinctive band throughout their
career and still going today. They have had more of an influence on the more metal
side of HC in contrast to The DKs which have influenced the more alternative
post HC side of things.
6. Bad Religion – How Could Hell be any Worse?
Melodic HC, is that a contradiction in terms. Maybe, maybe
not, who really cares. One thing is for sure though is that Bad Religion are
without a shadow of doubt the founding members of this style. So many releases
and so compelling, so active and a band which you can always go back to and
rely on.
5. Cro-Mags – Age of Quarrel
A band with a lot of bite! A great release and one of the
NYHC classics. Shame that they have had their problems and differences over the
years as it would have been good to have seen them carry on through the decades
like Agnostic Front have done.
4. Bad Brains – Bad Brains
Probably the most influential band on the early HC scene on
this list. Most people would have one of their releases in the top 3. For me,
one of their strengths, which is variety, is also a slight weakness as a HC
band. Maybe that is a limited way of looking at things, but it is how I look at
things. ‘Attitude’ and ‘The Big Takeover’ are great tunes, a band I would love
to see live.
3. Discharge – Hear Nothing, See Nothing, Say
Nothing
The first English band and only the second non American band
on the list. I saw one top 20 hardcore LPs list recently which didn't even have
Discharge in there. They created a whole sub genre of HC which is probably the
most numerous. Relentless!
2. Agnostic Front – Victim in Pain
What a band... an amazing 30 year history. Even though I
have picked their debut for this list they have released so many great LPs and
like a fine wine have got better over the years. The reason I picked their
debut is just the sheer amount of classics jammed onto here. Check out these 2 live clips. The first is
from 04 and the second is from 85. Pretty much the same guys playing the same
songs at the same venue. Both are amazing, but the 04 clip is one of the best
live videos I've ever seen. If you are reading this and not really into HC
check it out to find out what HC is all about.